PlateScore

Carniceria El Herradero

A°

1416 E Broadway Rd, Mesa 85204

Food Establishment - Eating & Drinking · Permit FD-90820

Score based on 12 scored inspections on record, weighted toward recent visits (one-year half-life). How scoring works

County record last checked Sep 22, 2026.

59
Poor

Mesa restaurant avg: 93

Compare with another

An inspection on Jul 20, 2026 found violations at the county's most serious (D-equivalent) level. Scores are held in the “Poor” band for 6 months after such events — until Jan 16, 2027, assuming no further incidents. How scoring works

Score over time

1000602023202420252026Nov 8, 2023 — Routine — score 25 (4 priority, 3 foundation, 0 core)Nov 21, 2023 — Re-Inspection — score 100 (0 priority, 0 foundation, 0 core)Apr 8, 2024 — Routine — score 100 (0 priority, 0 foundation, 0 core)Sep 9, 2024 — Routine — score 100 (0 priority, 0 foundation, 0 core)Nov 21, 2024 — Routine — score 95 (0 priority, 1 foundation, 0 core)Feb 5, 2025 — Routine — score 99 (0 priority, 0 foundation, 1 core)May 5, 2025 — Routine — score 99 (0 priority, 0 foundation, 1 core)Aug 18, 2025 — Routine — score 99 (0 priority, 0 foundation, 1 core)Jan 5, 2026 — Routine — score 80 (1 priority, 1 foundation, 0 core)Apr 13, 2026 — Routine — score 39 (4 priority, 0 foundation, 1 core)Jul 20, 2026 — Routine — score 40 (3 priority, 3 foundation, 0 core)Jul 30, 2026 — Re-Inspection — score 100 (0 priority, 0 foundation, 0 core)100
Score per routine inspection and re-inspection; dashed line marks the “Poor” threshold (60).

Inspection history14 on record

2026

Aug 3, 2026Advisorynot scoredclean
Jul 30, 2026Re-InspectioncleanA°

upon re-inspection, violations corrected. re-inspection report emailed to managerPredefined Comment: Upon re-inspection, all violations due for correction have been corrected.

Jul 23, 2026Advisorynot scoredclean
Jul 20, 2026Routine3 priority3 foundationD°

report emailed. re-inspection for the food cooler, and outdoor grilling handwashing station scheduled for 7-30-2026. will coordinate a Spanish AMC class for the facility staff and PIC. please visit esd.maricopa.gov for additioanl online resources. spanish translation was provided during the inspection for the kitchen pic and manager.Predefined Comment: Due to the violations noted on this inspection report, County legal action may result from this inspection.re-inspection for the salsa bar food cooler, and the outdoor grilling hand washing scheduled for 7-30-2026. informed manager. department food cooling guidance document reviewed. Spanish pdf provided.

#10 — Adequate Handwashing Sinks, Properly Supplied and AccessiblePriority foundation5-205.11

Inspector's notes

facility has an outdoor grilling area, in the front parking. the grilling station, hand washing not provided. showed photos on file regarding the approved equipment for hand washing station. manager was unable to setup during the inspection. scheduled a 10 day re-inspection. please ensure the portable hand washing stations is fully functional, has soap, paper towel and running mixed faucet providing minimum 100 deg f water. re-inspection scheduled for 7-30-2026 Corrective Action: Correct prior to re-inspection.

Show full county text

5-205.11 - Priority Foundation: Using a Handwashing Sink-Operation and Maintenance. For a permanent fix to this violation, check out these simple tools in our Active Managerial Control Toolbox, made especially for you. https://www.maricopa.gov/4573/AMC-Toolbox: Handwashing.

#20 — Proper Cooling Time and TemperaturesPriority3-501.14

Inspector's notes

observed pans of cooked pork in the upright cooler at 105-116 deg f . pans wrapped and covered. also pans of cooked chorizo in the food reach-in cooler back food prep. grill room wrapped , temperatures indicating 66 deg f . discussed with facility staff and manager via spanish department staff translating , strategies to ensure rapid food cooling. manager stated food cooked at 8-9am. suggested to place hot food in flat shallow pans and leave uncovered. use of ice bath and the facility walk-in cooler reviewed. manager removed all, placed in flat metal pans. 41 deg f established inside the walk-in cooler. Corrective Action: Corrected at time of inspection.

Show full county text

PRIORITY VIOLATION-3-501.14 - Priority: Cooling. For a permanent fix to this violation, check out these simple tools in our Active Managerial Control Toolbox, made especially for you. https://www.maricopa.gov/4617/AMC-Toolbox---Cooling.

#21 — Proper Hot Holding TemperaturesPriority3-501.16

Inspector's notes

observed at the left hot holding case in the front deli service area, food such as tamales, burritos, rice and beans at 105-110 deg f . per manager the three of the hot holding elements are not keeping adequate heat. via spanish translation , described to manager, not to use this unit till repaired or replaced. also the right hot case refried beans and cooked rice in the bags noted at 106-116 deg f . noted the sliding hot case door missing glass and partially wrapped with plastic wrap. manager stated they have ordered new plexi glass and awaiting the installation. please ensure rte/tcs food is kept at 135 deg f or higher. manager removed food. Corrective Action: Corrected at time of inspection.

Show full county text

PRIORITY VIOLATION-3-501.16(A)(1) - Priority: Time/Temperature Control for Safety Food, Hot Holding. For a permanent fix to this violation, check out these simple tools in our Active Managerial Control Toolbox, made especially for you. https://www.maricopa.gov/4614/AMC-Toolbox---Hot-Holding.

#22 — Proper Cold Holding TemperaturesPriority3-501.16

Inspector's notes

facility has a salsa bar in the dining area, self service, temperature of diced tomatoes, salsas with tomatoes, chopped, pico de gallo. all at 53 deg f . discussed with manager on duty. manager removed all tcs food . please ensure tcs food is kept at 41 deg f . see embargo Corrective Action: Corrected at time of inspection.

Show full county text

PRIORITY VIOLATION-3-501.16(A)(2) and (B) - Priority: Time/Temperature Control for Safety Food, Cold Holding. For a permanent fix to this violation, check out these simple tools in our Active Managerial Control Toolbox, made especially for you.https://www.maricopa.gov/4576/AMC-Toolbox---Cold-Holding.

#28 — Toxic Substances Properly Identified, Stored, and Used; Held for Retail Sale, Properly StoredPriority foundation7-202.11

Inspector's notes

observed in the back food prep. rooms, gallon sprayer of insecticide. discussed with manager. please only continue with a certified pest control company. manager discarded insecticides. Corrective Action: Corrected at time of inspection.

Show full county text

7-202.11 - Priority Foundation: Restriction-Presence and Use

#33 — Proper Cooling Methods Used; Adequate Equipment for Temperature ControlPriority foundation4-301.11

Inspector's notes

in the dining area, salsa bar station operating at 53 deg f . showed owner. PIC will place a work order. re-inspection scheduled for 10 days. 7-30-2026 please ensure food cooler can maintain 41 deg f or cooler.

Show full county text

4-301.11 - Priority Foundation: Cooling, Heating, and Holding Capacities-Equipment. For a permanent fix to this violation, check out these simple tools in our Active Managerial Control Toolbox, made especially for you. https://www.maricopa.gov/4617/AMC-Toolbox---Cooling.

Apr 13, 2026Routine4 priority1 coreD°

report emailed.Predefined Comment: No County legal action will result from this inspection.

#51 — Plumbing Installed; Proper Backflow DevicesCore5-205.15

Inspector's notes

observed drain line under the three-compartment basin, leaking onto the back-room floor. manager placed a service call. please ensure plumbing pipe/fixtures are properly secured/sealed connections. Corrective Action: Correct prior to next routine inspection.

Show full county text

5-205.15 (B) - Core: System Maintained in Good Repair; Maintained

#15 — Food Separated and ProtectedPriority3-302.11

Inspector's notes

observed raw chicken, in the walk-in cooler, placed atop meats, also raw ground meat pan placed atop cooked food in the back room, upright cooler. discussed the proper storage for raw and rte food. mcesd food storage guidance document reviewed. manager relocated raw chicken, and raw ground beef to a designated lower shelf. corrected Corrective Action: Corrected at time of inspection.

Show full county text

PRIORITY VIOLATION-3-302.11 (A1-2) - Priority: Packaged and Unpackaged Food-Separation, Packaging, and Segregation; Protection from Cross Contamination. For a permanent fix to this violation, check out these simple tools in our Active Managerial Control Toolbox, made especially for you. https://www.maricopa.gov/4621/AMC-Toolbox---Cross-Contamination.

#16 — Food-Contact Surfaces: Cleaned and SanitizedPriority4-501.114

Inspector's notes

observed the warewashing final basin, noted sanitizer at 0ppm. discussed with manager on duty and kitchen staff. manager showed staff , sanitizer was refilled to 50 ppm. Corrective Action: Corrected at time of inspection.

Show full county text

PRIORITY VIOLATION-4-501.114 (A-E) - Priority: Manual and Mechanical Warewashing Equipment, Chemical Sanitization- Temperature, pH, Concentration and Hardness. For a permanent fix to this violation, check out these simple tools in our Active Managerial Control Toolbox, made especially for you. https://www.maricopa.gov/4574/AMC-Toolbox---Food-Contact-Surfaces.

#21 — Proper Hot Holding TemperaturesPriority3-501.16

Inspector's notes

observed in the front service hot case, cooked rice bags at 112-116 deg f . also, spaghetti at 116-123 deg f . discussed with manager. all removed and reheated to 165 deg f . daily, temperature check recommended. manager stated, they will start monitoring hot holding more frequently. please ensure rte/ tcs food is kept at 135 deg f or higher. Corrective Action: Corrected at time of inspection.

Show full county text

PRIORITY VIOLATION-3-501.16(A)(1) - Priority: Time/Temperature Control for Safety Food, Hot Holding. For a permanent fix to this violation, check out these simple tools in our Active Managerial Control Toolbox, made especially for you. https://www.maricopa.gov/4614/AMC-Toolbox---Hot-Holding.

#23 — Proper Date Marking and DispositionPriority3-501.18

Inspector's notes

observed in the food upright cooler back food prep. room, near back entry, pans of cooler rice date 4-1-2026. also on site prepared salsa with diced/chopped tomatoes dated 3-29. discussed with manager. all removed. mcesd use by date and discard procedure reviewed with manager. Corrective Action: Corrected at time of inspection.

Show full county text

PRIORITY VIOLATION-3-501.18 - Priority: Ready-To-Eat Time/Temperature Control for Safety Food, Disposition. For a permanent fix to this violation, check out these simple tools in our Active Managerial Control Toolbox, made especially for you. https://www.maricopa.gov/4125/Food-SafetyOperator-Resources.

Jan 5, 2026Routine1 priority1 foundationall corrected on siteB

report emailed.Predefined Comment: No County legal action will result from this inspection.

#10 — Adequate Handwashing Sinks, Properly Supplied and AccessiblePriority foundation6-301.12

Inspector's notes

observed at the food prep. restroom, hand washing stations, paper towel dispensers were in disrepair. unable to pull paper towel out. discussed with facility manager. manager serviced both paper towel dispensers. corrected Corrective Action: Corrected at time of inspection.

Show full county text

6-301.12 - Priority Foundation: Hand Drying Provision. For a permanent fix to this violation, check out these simple tools in our Active Managerial Control Toolbox, made especially for you. https://www.maricopa.gov/4573/AMC-Toolbox: Handwashing.

#21 — Proper Hot Holding TemperaturesPriority3-501.16

Inspector's notes

observed at the hot station, service case, cooked beef, and cooked chickens at 119-122 deg f . discussed the proper hot holding, minimum 135 deg f . suggested to ensure all case doors are kept closed, and also to ensure steam table setting is properly adjusted. noted one of the cases, glass door removed missing. sliding door was partially wrapped with plastic wrap. please ensure the door is fully functional, seal the plastic penetrations. manager reheated steam table and reheated food. 165 deg f established. Corrective Action: Corrected at time of inspection.

Show full county text

PRIORITY VIOLATION-3-501.16(A)(1) - Priority: Time/Temperature Control for Safety Food, Hot Holding. For a permanent fix to this violation, check out these simple tools in our Active Managerial Control Toolbox, made especially for you. https://www.maricopa.gov/4614/AMC-Toolbox---Hot-Holding.

2025

Aug 18, 2025Routine1 coreA

Predefined Comment: No County legal action will result from this inspection.Copy of inspection provided to PIC via email.

#2 — Certified Food Protection ManagerCore2-102.12

Inspector's notes

At time of inspection, no CFPM was on site. Corrective Action: Correct prior to next routine inspection.

Show full county text

2-102.12(A) - Core: Certified Food Protection Manager. For a permanent fix to this violation, check out these resources on our website. https://www.maricopa.gov/5114/Food-Restaurants Predefined Comment: A Certified Food Protection Manager (CFPM) is required to be on the premises during all hours of operation.

May 5, 2025Routine1 coreA

Predefined Comment: No County legal action will result from this inspection.Copy of inspection provided to PIC via email.

#2 — Certified Food Protection ManagerCore2-102.12

Inspector's notes

At time of inspection, no CFPM was on site. Corrective Action: Correct prior to next routine inspection.

Show full county text

2-102.12(A) - Core: Certified Food Protection Manager. For a permanent fix to this violation, check out these resources on our website. https://www.maricopa.gov/5114/Food-Restaurants Predefined Comment: A Certified Food Protection Manager (CFPM) is required to be on the premises during all hours of operation.

Feb 5, 2025Routine1 coreA

Predefined Comment: No County legal action will result from this inspection.Copy of inspection provided to PIC via email.

#2 — Certified Food Protection ManagerCore2-102.12

Inspector's notes

At time of inspection, no CFPM was on site. Corrective Action: Correct prior to next routine inspection.

Show full county text

2-102.12(A) - Core: Certified Food Protection Manager. For a permanent fix to this violation, check out these resources on our website. https://www.maricopa.gov/5114/Food-Restaurants Predefined Comment: A Certified Food Protection Manager (CFPM) is required to be on the premises during all hours of operation.

2024

Nov 21, 2024Routine1 foundationall corrected on siteB°

Predefined Comment: No County legal action will result from this inspection.Copy of inspection provided to PIC vi a email.

#10 — Adequate Handwashing Sinks, Properly Supplied and AccessiblePriority foundation5-205.11

Inspector's notes

Observed hand washing station next to the 3 compartment sink completely block by merch and other items. It also had multiple utensils inside the basin. PIC organized handwashing station area and removed any unnecessary items at time of inspection. Handwashing station must be accessible at all times. Corrective Action: Corrected at time of inspection.

Show full county text

5-205.11 - Priority Foundation: Using a Handwashing Sink-Operation and Maintenance. For a permanent fix to this violation, check out these simple tools in our Active Managerial Control Toolbox, made especially for you. https://www.maricopa.gov/4573/AMC-Toolbox: Handwashing. Predefined Comment: PIC relocated all items blocking handwash sink at time of inspection.

Sep 9, 2024RoutinecleanA

Predefined Comment: No County legal action will result from this inspection.Copy of inspection provided to PIC via email.

Apr 8, 2024RoutinecleanA

This establishment received a(n) A Grade and had 0 Priority, 0 Priority Foundation violations on this inspection.Copy of inspection provided to PIC via email. Notes:The Environmental Services Department will begin emailing permit card(s) and permit invoice(s) to permittees in the coming months. We need a current and accurate email address on file to ensure you receive a copy of your permit card and invoice(s) upon renewal.If you are unsure whether your email address is accurate, you may:• Contact your inspector using the phone number or email on your last inspection report to review, or• Contact the Department using the email addresses below,o Envquickservicerestaurants@maricopa.gov (facilities such as fast-food)o Envfullservicerestaurants@maricopa.gov (facilities that are full-service restaurants)o Envretailgrocery@maricopa.gov (facilities like grocery stores or retail food markets)o Envspecialtyprograms@maricopa.gov (mobile food/special events/plan review)Note: If you need to update your email address and/or other contact information, please submit an administrative change request form at the below websitehttps://www.maricopa.gov/FormCenter/Environmental-Services-16/Administrative-Change-Request-Form-181 or call 602-506-6824.No County legal action will result from this inspection.Award: A,Signer: Nieves Debora

2023

Nov 21, 2023Re-InspectioncleanA°

Upon re-inspection, violations #22 & 31 have been corrected.Copy of Re-inspection provided to PIC via email. No County legal action will result from this inspection.Award: Re-Inspection,Signer: Susy Olivera

Nov 8, 2023Routine4 priority3 foundationD

This establishment received a(n) D Grade and had 4 Priority, 3 Priority Foundation violations on this inspection.FDA 01 2-102.12(A), C – Certified Food Protection Manager• No employee with supervisory and management responsibility with the authority to direct and control food preparation that is deemed a certified food protection manager.• The certified food protection manager certificate is deemed not to be from an accredited program. Inspection conducted with RS#789Copy of inspection provided to PIC via email. Notes:Re-inspection will occur no later than 11/16/2023Strongly recommended to seal the flooring in the kitchen area. If there's any damage in the future to the kitchen floor, it is advised to replace it with a material that it is smooth, non absorbent and easily cleanable. If establishment does not have its own employees drink section, personal drinks should be kept at a lower shelf away from any possible cross-contamination at all times.The Environmental Services Department will begin emailing permit card(s) and permit invoice(s) to permittees in the coming months. We need a current and accurate email address on file to ensure you receive a copy of your permit card and invoice(s) upon renewal.If you are unsure whether your email address is accurate, you may:• Contact your inspector using the phone number or email on your last inspection report to review, or• Contact the Department using the email addresses below,o Envquickservicerestaurants@maricopa.gov (facilities such as fast-food)o Envfullservicerestaurants@maricopa.gov (facilities that are full-service restaurants)o Envretailgrocery@maricopa.gov (facilities like grocery stores or retail food markets)o Envspecialtyprograms@maricopa.gov (mobile food/special events/plan review)Note: If you need to update your email address and/or other contact information, please submit an administrative change request form at the below websitehttps://www.maricopa.gov/FormCenter/Environmental-Services-16/Administrative-Change-Request-Form-181 or call 602-506-6824.No County legal action will result from this inspection.Award: D,Embargo Lbs: 8,Review Complete: CHECKED,Review Notes: RA--- Noneval TEW,Signer: Nieves Debora

#15 — Food Separated and ProtectedPriority3-302.11

PRIORITY VIOLATION-3-302.11 (A1-2), P: Packaged and Unpackaged Food-Separation, Packaging, and Segregation; Protection From Cross Contamination. For a permanent fix to this violation, check out these simple tools in our Active Managerial Control Toolbox, made especially for you. https://www.maricopa.gov/4621/AMC-Toolbox---Cross-Contamination.--Observed inside the fridge at the back of the kitchen multiple packages of raw bacon being stored directly above RTE food, such as vegetables and cheeses. PIC moved bacon to the lowest shelf at time of inspection, away from any possible cross-contamination. Correct By: Corrected At Time Of Inspection

#21 — Proper Hot Holding TemperaturesPriority3-501.16

PRIORITY VIOLATION-3-501.16(A)(1), P: Time/Temperature Control for Safety Food, Hot Holding. For a permanent fix to this violation, check out these simple tools in our Active Managerial Control Toolbox, made especially for you. https://www.maricopa.gov/4614/AMC-Toolbox---Hot-Holding.---Observed at the deli inside the hot holding unit cooked items such as chiles rellenos, beef rib and salsa verde pork holding an internal temperature of 120 *F. Per PIC the hot holding unit has been having some problems but a work order already has been submitted and they are just waiting for some parts to arrive. It was been a week and half since they submitted the work order. All those cooked items were no longer than 30 minutes inside the hot case, PIC reheated and moved those meats to another working hot holding unit at time of inspection. Correct By: Corrected At Time Of Inspection

#22 — Proper Cold Holding TemperaturesPriority3-501.16

PRIORITY VIOLATION-3-501.16(A)(2) and (B), P: Time/Temperature Control for Safety Food, Cold Holding. For a permanent fix to this violation, check out these simple tools in our Active Managerial Control Toolbox, made especially for you. https://www.maricopa.gov/4576/AMC-Toolbox---Cold-Holding.---Observed at the salsa bar green salsa, red salsa, avocado salsa, pico de gallo and lettuce holding at an internal temperature of 49*F. Per PIC all these items have been placed there since 10:00 am. PIC discarded salsa at time of inspection, replaced metal containers with deeper containers and also moved the temperature setting to the unit to the coldest setting 1. Cold holding unit was on setting 6 when inspected. Correct By: Corrected At Time Of Inspection

#24 — Time as a Public Health Control: Procedures and RecordsPriority foundation3-501.19

Priority Foundation-3-501.19 (A1, B2, C2-3), Pf: Time as a Public Health Control; Documentation. For a permanent fix to this violation, check out these simple tools in our Active Managerial Control Toolbox, made especially for you. https://www.maricopa.gov/4125/Food-SafetyOperator-Resources. Per PIC, establishment uses time as a control for the chicharron inside the hot holding case but no records were available at time of inspection. PIC will write a time as a control policy and will keep track of the chicharron with a max 4 hour window. Re-inspection will occur no later than 11/16/2023. Correct By: Correct Prior To Reinspection

#28 — Toxic Substances Properly Identified, Stored, and Used; Held for Retail Sale, Properly StoredPriority foundation7-102.11

Priority Foundation-7-102.11, Pf: Common Name-Working Containers---Observed multiple spray bottles located at the back of the kitchen, near the 3 compartment sink without any labels on. Per PIC three of them had degreaser and one had water inside. PIC labeled all containers at time of inspection. PRIORITY VIOLATION-7-204.11, P: Sanitizers, Criteria-Chemicals---Observed at 3 compartment sink chlorine sanitizer level below 50 ppm. Per PIC an employee did not properly set up the sanitizer this morning. PIC put more bleach to sanitizer compartment, reaching a concentration of least 50 ppm at time of inspection. Correct By: Corrected At Time Of Inspection

#33 — Proper Cooling Methods Used; Adequate Equipment for Temperature ControlPriority foundation4-301.11

Priority Foundation-4-301.11, Pf: Cooling, Heating, and Holding Capacities-Equipment. For a permanent fix to this violation, check out these simple tools in our Active Managerial Control Toolbox, made especially for you. https://www.maricopa.gov/4617/AMC-Toolbox---Cooling.---Observed part of hot holding case at the deli area reaching a maximum temperature of 120 *F. Re-inspection will occur no later than 11/16/2023. Correct By: Correct Prior To Reinspection

This address holds 4 food permits

Maricopa County issues a separate permit for each kitchen rather than for each restaurant name, so large properties hold several. Each is inspected and scored on its own. The county does not publish which kitchen serves which venue.

Nearby restaurants

Other places to eat within a short walk, with their current scores.

Data from Maricopa County Environmental Services public records, last checked Sep 22, 2026. Grades marked with ° are computed equivalents for establishments not participating in the county's voluntary grading program. View official county records →